top of page

15. Interpreting Nature to Improve an Economy

How to compare 2 complex yet similar systems to fill in the gaps of our knowledge and understanding

15. Interpreting Nature to Improve an Economy

I always liked to study similar systems in NATURE (divinely blessed) to solve any problems in the manually designed system that I am involved with. I sincerely believe such comparison helps and is a useful exercise in building knowledge.

If you compare 2 complex systems, each can benefit from the influence of the knowledge gained from the other system! This article is based on this simple fundamental premise.


Let us compare agriculture with common economic problems/issues.

The various types of crops are food crops (staple foods), feed crops (for livestock consumption), fibre crops (cotton, hemp etc., for making clothes/fibres), oil crops (for consumption or industrial use – corn, cottonseed), ornamental crops (for landscaping and aesthetics) and industrial crops (e.g. Rubber, tobacco)

Set 1: Food/Feed/Fibre crops – supporting essential needs

Set 2: Oil/Ornamental/Industrial crops – supporting non-essential functions or to provide comfort

Since Set 1 is essential (life and living activities depends on this), national economies and global governing entities should land this safely before attempting to gain profits out of Set 2.

 

Similarly various economic units exist such as – Global Economy, Regional Economy, Country Economy, State/Province Economy, District/County Economy and City Economy.

If we consider Country as a primary governing entity (since you need to implement policies satisfying the people of the nation), the below understanding helps.

Set 1: Country Economy, State Economy and County/City Economy

Set 2: Economy within Trade blocks

(Please refer to my blog - https://www.mayoan.com/economy/01.-an-alternate-view-on-economics )

Set 3: Global Economy, Regional Economy

Set 1 above is most important before you focus on Set 3. Set 2 is relatively next in priority after considering Set 1.


For example, National leaders should support global corporations only if adequate benefits materialise in terms of persisting income/employment and advancement within its national boundaries or secondarily within the trade blocks that has symbiotic arrangement with the host nation. It cannot accept a global corporation if it carries a significant stability related risk that can possibly ruin the national economy (institutions with Systemic Risks).


Let us consider some of the major problems in Economy and compare it with its closest concepts in agriculture:


1.      Employment and Unemployment in the Economy

There can be permanent or temporary workers in the agriculture. There can be workers in the preparation, production and distribution functions in the agriculture. While the permanent ones are the ones that are employed to monitor and cure the crops till harvesting, temporary workers are needed seasonally – while planting or while harvesting and distributing.  The temporary workers should be used for storage/maintenance & distribution, animal husbandry, plant and equipment maintenance etc., till they revert to the seasonal agricultural assignments. Thus there will be more constancy in the labour demand. Predictability is easy.

Reckless automation/mechanizations should be avoided – These things build profits at scale for host organizations but snatch away employment opportunities. To some degree this issue can be best tackled by a co-operative model implemented for farms where there will be harmony between men and machines – men belong to constituent unit of the co-operative structure and machines belong to the co-operative structure itself and can be rented out with operators when needed. It is better to balance it with sound principles.

The same principles should be used for the labour management in a national or regional economies. Please refer to my blog article - https://www.mayoan.com/economy/14.-some-labour-market-observations-and-ideas .

Understand the labour market and implement those principles that provide stability to the various job functions. You do this while building the job profiles of the various essential job roles needed in the economy. If necessary, understand the job roles that are to be newly created, improved and obsoleted and develop necessary implementation plans including imparting job-related trainings at scale and thus improve employability of the nation’s citizens. Also, focus on the product/produce flows (or input-work-output – chain of events)  to build co-operative, sustainable networks of organizations/institutions that ensure some degree of stability and ensure predictability.

 

2.      Interest Rates

This is an important monitory policy used to control money supply and borrowing costs. This operation should not alter the foundation layer of the economy agreed by experts as defined by employment rate, GDP and some securities promised by the constitution. (Please refer to my article at- https://www.mayoan.com/economy/13.-some-strategies-meant-for-a-pro-people-government). So, the government should ensure discipline and some basic sanity check in foreign exchange reserves, foreign trades, exchange rates and balance of payments before trying to adjust this. The target objectives for interest rate manipulations should be a SMART goal (SMART goals   are  Specific,  Measurable,  Achievable,  Relevant, and  Time-bound )  and not a moving target whose surrounding interpreted data is constantly mangled, not-useful and confusing. I vaguely remember, in high schools, we were taught partial differential equations to solve such complex systems with many significant parameters. So, we should use information technology to the right effect to identify the SMART goal and the necessary monitoring & controlling needed along with the recommendations on the corrective actions needed.

Simple – If the system is too complex and with lot of moving parts, don’t try to correct it randomly – try to identify the ‘ONE’ or ‘TWO’ things that yields maximum results while we keep other things constant. This will need a lot of R&D before we act.

 

This can be compared to the laying of fertilizers on the land. Too much or too little can cause problem. The target strength – high or low can alter the effect. Continuous use may spoil the soil and possibly poison it. And there should be a natural way to cleanse it out before the next crop cycle since the fertilizer needed for the next crop may be different.  

3.      Inflation

‘Inflation refers to the general increase in prices or the money-supply both of which can cause the purchasing power of a currency to decline’.

We can directly relate this to the glut in the production or in the stagnation of the produce. But, for better understanding of the comparison, we have to shift our focus to the consumers of the agricultural products too and not just the farm or the farmers.

In the first case, consider Excess money in the economy as Excess produce available to the public (similar to increase in money supply)

Customers are inundated with the same type of produce. This has the power to disrupt the farming community as the price of the goods drops. Excess money sometimes leads to substandard outcome like low-quality loans and mortgages.

Farming community manages this risk through farm insurance, commercial buy-back arrangements with food companies, and by developing good reliable storage and distribution facilities. Similarly excessive money in economy should be controlled by appropriately controlling interest rates, proper hedging of financial reserves and money market operations etc.,

In the second case, consider Price Increase as Low yield (increase in commodity prices)

Customers find the produce to be inadequate in quantity and hence the price jumps. Hence customers cannot buy other essential things.  This has to be controlled by the farming community by practising appropriate due diligence in farming operations and processes and with continuous monitoring and control and with appropriate use of fertilizers and pesticides/insecticides. Similarly good financial discipline including discipline with our import/export situations and enforcement can save us from price increase. Remember – price increase can be beneficial for an organization but despite tax income it may not necessarily benefit the nation in long term. Thus, appropriate regulations should be in effect, possibly along with enforcements like MRP (Maximum Retail Pricing). If the economy is strong, other measures like temporary imports can be leveraged.

 

All, of the above will work only when we have strong data & data analysis skills/talents deployed over our monitoring, controlling and continuously improving system of governance.

References:

Crop | Definition, Types, & Facts | Britannica

Inflation | Definition, Theories, & Facts | Britannica Money

© 2035  Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page